Sunday, October 18, 2009

Exercises After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

Open or Closed Kinetic Chain Exercises After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction


I wanted to post about a recent research paper I was reading titled “Open- or Closed-Kinetic Chain Exercises After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction”.

I was reading this research paper because from strength and conditioning/sports performance point of view I believe in Closed-Kinetic Chain exercises, but I also work with several client that have had past ACL injuries and I am open to anything that will make them a better athlete! The most interesting thing I found was that “OKC and CKC exercises for rehabilitation of the ACL-reconstructed was the load differences may not be clinically significant and that both exercise types, in combination, may be important for ACL rehabilitation. Additional prospective randomized clinical trials must be performed to determine the optimal time to introduce these exercises”

I would have to say that within the last year I have come across more athletes/ clients looking for guidance and training after coming out of physical therapy and wanting to get back into playing full speed. And more and more I am seeing major problems with the athlete being told they are “cleared to play at full speed”. Most of the athletes that have come to me from a port rehab setting have only performed minimal OKC exercises at the least. I have found that no balance or stability drills have been incorporated into the rehab program. I think this is where most athletes do not understand just because they are cleared from a PT that they are ready to go running full speed on the field! This is where a quality performance specialist should come into play! This is not to say all PT's are not adequately providing their clients with the necessary exercises for proper rehabilitation, but most rehab centers are not designed to develop the athletic ability needed to perform at a high level. The job of a PT is to get you back into normal everyday living.

**OKC exercises as those in which the foot is not in contact with a solid surface (Leg extensions)

**CKC exercises as those in which the foot is in contact with a solid surface. (Squat, Lunge)


Brian Van Hook
VH Sports Performance – Las Vegas, NV


1. Braden C. Fleming, Heidi Oksendahl, Bruce D. Beynnon. Open or Closed Kinetic Chain Exercises After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction. Exerc. Sport Sci. Rev. 2005. Vol. 33, No. 3, pp. 134–140

4 comments:

MScottDPT said...

Hey Brian,

As a physical therapist I think that it is important to hear what strength and conditioning professionals have to say about the athletes they are getting once they are "cleared" from therapy. I agree with your observation that many athletes do not get proper education regarding what cleared from therapy actually means, but I also have to clearify your closing statement that a PT's job is to get people back to everyday life.

Sure, getting people back to "everyday life" is a physical therapist's job, but what if everyday life for someone means taking part in summer league basketball, training for a marathon, or just getting to the gym four times a week? It is our job to get them back to this activity level as well, not just walking up and down stairs. Unfortunately, many physical therapists do not have the proper training or education to advance patients to this level.

This is where PT's like me and CSCS's like you work great together. As professionals, we can have 2 sets of eyes on trends that we are beginning to see. CSCS's can bring their education and training to the table and PT's can bring theirs to help recovering athletes reach their full potential.

I appreciate your outlook and opinions on what you are seeing with athletes coming out of PT's clinics, and if you would like to discuss this further you can contct me at mikescott.dpt@gmail.com, on twitter at mscottdpt, or at www.prevention-plus.blogspot.com

-Mike Scott, DPT

Brian Van Hook said...

Thanks Mike for your comment, and clarification to the post. You are right, what if daily living is a five mile run? I agree that working together is the key to helping an athlete (or anyone for that matter) to gain what they have lost and get back to their full potential and hopeful beyond.

I will defiantly be contacting you to know what your thoughts are in regard to ACL reduction and rehabilitation strategy or tips.

Tim Caron said...

Brian I enjoyed your post about the difference between the two types exercises. The research you have found has indicated that it is appropriate to do both; but wouldnt having a progression towards closed chain movements be ideal? I say that because closed chain movements are where you are trying to end up at. Life/sport is with the feet on the ground and the muscular structures that support the knee joint are utilized differently then in a open kinetic chain exercise and you must prepare your athlete/client for that.

It seems as though the progression from a physical therapist to performance coach is one that could be ideal (along proper lines of communication). I work at the collegiate level, and I have the great fortune of having the surgeon/rehab specialist at my disposal when I need advice or clearance with my post op athletes. I know that the rehab protocol is based on isolation movements that will increase the tensile strength of the repaired ligament. This to me is necessary in order to accomplish my primarily closed chain program.

Do you have a protocol for post op ACL tear clients? I would be very interested to see your progression if you dont mind.

Thanks,

Tim Caron, MS, CSCS

Brian Van Hook said...

Hello Tim Thanks for the comment; sorry about the delay, the holidays have keep me busy.
I do think it’s appropriate to do both, but I always lean towards closed chain movements when working with just about every population. I have never been a huge fan of OKC, but I do see the need for them in specific situations. I like closed chain for the same reason you stated (basically, you should be able to support yourself on the ground). I think isolation movements are ideal when starting a rehab program, but on the other hand I have also seen athletes come out of a rehab program where they feel the injured leg is stronger than the non-injured leg? At that point I think they are spending too much time on open chain exercises and isolation movements.
I think we have similar thought on the subject; I have to say most of my progressions for leg injuries have come from Mike Robertson’s “Bulletproof Knees”; his manual really gave me some great info and ideas on designing a quality program for athletes with knee injuries. I have also found that working on the hips and ankles as well as the knee has been of great value when getting the athlete back to competition.
I have a basic outline I can email you (I will send it to your blog email) I always make changes to it for the individual person as needed.

Thanks again for the comment.
Brian